Citation

Price O, Armitage CJ, Bee P, Brooks H, Lovell K, Butler D, Cree L, Fishwick P, Grundy A, Johnston I, McPherson P, Riches H, Scott A, Walker L, Papastavrou Brooks C. BMC Psychiatry 2024; 24(1): e548.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2024, Holtzbrinck Springer Nature Publishing Group - BMC)

DOI

10.1186/s12888-024-05920-y

PMID

39107709

Abstract

BACKGROUND: De-escalation is often advocated to reduce harm associated with violence and use of restrictive interventions, but there is insufficient understanding of factors that influence de-escalation behaviour in practice. For the first time, using behaviour change and implementation science methodology, this paper aims to identify the drivers that will enhance de-escalation in acute inpatient and psychiatric intensive care mental health settings.

METHODS: Secondary analysis of 46 qualitative interviews with ward staff (n = 20) and patients (n = 26) informed by the Theoretical Domains Framework.

RESULTS: Capabilities for de-escalation included knowledge (impact of trauma on memory and self-regulation and the aetiology and experience of voice hearing) and skills (emotional self-regulation, distress validation, reducing social distance, confirming autonomy, setting limits and problem-solving). Opportunities for de-escalation were limited by dysfunctional risk management cultures/ relationships between ward staff and clinical leadership, and a lack of patient involvement in safety maintenance. Motivation to engage in de-escalation was limited by negative emotion associated with moral formulations of patients and internal attributions for behaviour.

CONCLUSION: In addition to training that enhances knowledge and skills, interventions to enhance de-escalation should target ward and organisational cultures, as well as making fundamental changes to the social and physical structure of inpatient mental health wards. Psychological interventions targeting negative emotion in staff are needed to increase motivation. This paper provides a new evidence-based framework of indicative changes that will enhance de-escalation in adult acute mental health inpatient and PICU settings.

Language: en

Keywords

Humans; Adult; Female; Male; Middle Aged; Attitude of Health Personnel; Violence; Psychiatry; Aggression; Mental health; Psychiatric Department, Hospital; *Qualitative Research; *Aggression/psychology; *Inpatients/psychology; De-escalation; Mental Disorders/psychology/therapy; Qualitative