Citation

Hatcher S, Sharon C, House A, Collings S, Parag V, Collins N. Trials 2011; 12: e135.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2011, Holtzbrinck Springer Nature Publishing Group - BMC)

DOI

10.1186/1745-6215-12-135

PMID

21615951

PMCID

PMC3117717

Abstract

BACKGROUND: People who present to hospital after intentionally harming themselves pose a common and important problem. Previous reviews of interventions have been inconclusive as existing trials have been under powered and done on unrepresentative populations. These reviews have however indicated that problem solving therapy and regular written communications after the self-harm attempt may be an effective treatment. This protocol describes a large pragmatic trial of a package of measures which include problem solving therapy, regular written communication, patient support, cultural assessment, improved access to primary care and a risk management strategy in people who present to hospital after self-harm using a novel design.
METHODS: We propose to use a double consent Zelen design where participants are randomised prior to giving consent to enroll a large representative cohort of patients. The main outcome will be hospital attendance following repetition of self-harm, in the 12 months after recruitment with secondary outcomes of self reported self-harm, hopelessness, anxiety, depression, quality of life, social function and hospital use at three months and one year.
DISCUSSION: A strength of the study is that it is a pragmatic trial which aims to recruit large numbers and does not exclude people if English is not their first language. A potential limitation is the analysis of the results which is complex and may underestimate any effect if a large number of people refuse their consent in the group randomised to problem solving therapy as they will effectively cross over to the treatment as usual group. However the primary analysis is a true intention to treat analysis of everyone randomised which includes both those who consent and do not consent to participate in the study. This provides information about how the intervention will work in practice in a representative population which is a major advance in this study compared to what has been done before.
TRIAL REGISTRATION: Australia and New Zealand Clinical Trials Register (ANZCTR): ACTRN12609000641291.

Language: en

Keywords

Humans; Communication; Research Design; Cultural Characteristics; Anxiety; Depression; New Zealand; Psychiatric Status Rating Scales; Hospitalization; Time Factors; Self-Injurious Behavior; Treatment Outcome; Health Services Accessibility; Surveys and Questionnaires; Quality of Life; Primary Health Care; Social Behavior; Patient Acceptance of Health Care; Recurrence; Problem Solving; Correspondence as Topic