Citation

Honea JC, Keller SN, McNeill V. J. Mens Health 2022; 18(1).

Copyright

(Copyright © 2022, IMR Press)

DOI

10.31083/j.jomh1801020

PMID

unavailable

Abstract

BACKGROUND: To explore the differences in young adult male and female attitudes towards and motivations for suicide, beliefs about help-seeking behavior, and attitudes towards helping others to prevent suicide.

METHODS: In-depth interviews and focus groups with adolescent and young adult males and females (n = 50, ages 14-24) were conducted before and after a community-based play on suicide prevention. Two focus groups and 30 individual interviews (n = 50, 22 males, 28 females) were conducted before the intervention at one location, and 12 in-depth interviews (4 males, 8 females) were conducted with some of the same individuals after the play. The transcripts were coded by two independent coders for gender differences. Emergent categories were analyzed to identify differences in responses to issues surrounding suicide and depression.

RESULTS: Three key gender differences were found in communication styles around emotional vulnerabilities: (1) Females were more likely to talk about the importance of reaching out to others and giving counsel, while males were more likely to expect others in need to seek them out for help. (2) Females talked about psychological distress as something"everyone" experiences, while males tended to see their suffering as an individual phenomenon. (3) Females tended to advocate disclosure while males talked about the pressure not to talk about personal problems.

CONCLUSIONS: Young males and females may need different coping strategies, and interventions, therefore, must be tailored to address the needs of each gender separately. Campaigns and programs specifically for men should address the barriers that men face with disclosure and help-seeking, and strategies should be sensitive to the expectations of heteronormative masculinity. © 2022 The Author(s).

Language: en

Keywords

adult; human; suicide; Suicide; female; male; Gender differences; suicidal ideation; prevalence; sex difference; social support; suicide attempt; Suicide prevention; major depression; stigma; empowerment; controlled study; distress syndrome; interpersonal communication; clinical article; coping behavior; patient attitude; patient counseling; Article; mental health care personnel; help seeking behavior; young adult; Help-seeking behavior; emotional vulnerability