SAFETYLIT WEEKLY UPDATE

We compile citations and summaries of about 400 new articles every week.
RSS Feed

HELP: Tutorials | FAQ
CONTACT US: Contact info

Search Results

Journal Article

Citation

Mesu RC, Sauzeau D, Mugnier G, Fournis G, Garre JB, Gohier B. Ann. Med. Psychol. (Paris) 2018; 176(3): 249-255.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2018, Societe Medico-Psychologique, Publisher Elsevier Publishing)

DOI

10.1016/j.amp.2017.02.015

PMID

unavailable

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: The French Mental Health Act was reformed by the law of July 5th 2011, adding new and useful tools in the therapeutic management of the mentally ill, such as the possibility of involuntary admission to a psychiatric ward in case of an "imminent danger" and involuntary psychiatric treatment in outpatient settings. In France, these measures concern over 100,000 hospital stays a year. We wished to test the hypothesis that there is no statistical distinction between groups of patients with different types of admission orders. Material and methods: We designed an observational, retrospective, single-centre study. Inclusions in the sample concerned all adults (aged 18 or above) involuntarily admitted to the specialised psychiatric centre of the Sarthe county between November 1st 2013 and October 31st 2014. A single follow-up took place 60 days after the admission order had been pronounced and included data extracted from administrative and medical files.

RESULTS: For the purpose of the study, each new admission was treated as a new "case". Thus, 510 cases have been included in the main sample: 342 admitted upon a third persons' application (67.1%), 115 for imminent danger (22.5%) and 53 upon the state's representative decision (10.4%). Follow-up data showed the average duration of involuntary treatment to be significantly higher between the first two groups, 31.8 vs. 26.1 days respectively (p = 0.03). The state's representative group shared distinct clinical characteristics (p ≤ 0.05) in terms of sex-ratio, initial application setting, length of involuntary treatment and hospital stay, as well as diagnosis, history of suicide attempt, rate of judicial hearings and care programming upon discharge from hospital.

DISCUSSION: Our initial hypothesis was rejected. The type of measure was indeed significantly associated with different outcomes 60 days after admission. As was the case in other recent studies, the "imminent danger" group made up a significant part of the sample, highlighting its usefulness in emergency settings. This subgroup benefited from shorter hospital stays and had a significant tendency to see their admission order revoked at an earlier stage than in the case of a third party's application. This suggests that the incapacity to consent to treatment is less likely to last in the "imminent danger" group, although overall clinical characteristics are shared with the "third party" sub-sample. On the contrary, the combined "state's representative decision" group differed significantly from the rest of the sample on clinical grounds, especially a higher prevalence of psychotic disorders and a lower one for mood disorders. This could contribute to the higher rate of outpatient care programmes.

CONCLUSION: Our study points out some of the differences involving admission groups in psychiatric centers and is coherent with previous findings. However, given its single-centre approach and the notorious disparity of clinical practices over the national territory, it would be useful to include larger, nationwide samples, in order to assess the new Health Act's impact and to guide future public health decisions. © 2017 Elsevier Masson SAS


Language: en

Keywords

adult; human; female; male; suicide attempt; major clinical study; mental disease; controlled study; sex ratio; retrospective study; length of stay; medicolegal aspect; follow up; clinical decision making; Involuntary treatment; Psychiatric hospitalization; Article; observational study; involuntary commitment; medical history; treatment duration; Care program; Liberty and custody judge

NEW SEARCH


All SafetyLit records are available for automatic download to Zotero & Mendeley
Print