Citation

Gilligan J. Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy 2016; 30(2): 125-137.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2016, Association for Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy in the National Health Service)

DOI

10.1080/02668734.2016.1169768

PMID

unavailable

Abstract

As the most adequate theory of human personality yet created, including our propensity for irrational, self-defeating, and self-destructive behavior patterns, psychoanalysis is in a unique position to help us solve the most serious crisis that the human species has been confronted by at any point in its evolutionary history: the threat to its own survival that is caused by its own behavior, namely the compulsion to engage in violence on the largest scale that its technology makes possible, even when that causes the death of the self as well as of others. This continually expanding behavior pattern, which reduces even genocide to a minor footnote compared with the self-extinction of our whole species, is created not only by "apocalyptic" fundamentalism and terrorism ("suicide bombers"), but also by the increasing and only partially preventable proliferation of thermonuclear weapons to national rulers of questionable sanity, and the apparently unpreventable continuation of industrial/economic policies and practices that will, if not reversed, make our own small planet uninhabitable. What makes people place a higher value on the continuation of these behaviors than they place on their own physical survival (or that of their children)? That is the question to which this article proposes at least the beginnings of an answer: that when a person feels shamed and humiliated to a degree that threatens the survival of that fragile and vulnerable psychological construct called his "self" (or of the religious or cultural group with which his self has identified), he will eagerly sacrifice his body (and other peoples') in the attempt to, as he sees it, save his soul, i.e. his self and his self-esteem. The question then becomes: what are the social and psychological determinants of overwhelming shame and humiliation, and how can we protect people from being exposed to those conditions, or at least enhance their ability to respond to them in ways that are life-preserving rather than life-destroying? © 2016 The Association for Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy in the NHS.

Language: en

Keywords

human; cognition; violence; morality; preventive medicine; public health; Shame; psychoanalysis; behavior; priority journal; emotion; guilt; self esteem; self evaluation; prophylaxis; thinking; science; ego development; Article; self defense; genocide; cognitive development; extinction; self examination