Citation

Zhang Y, Li H, Ren G. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2023; 190: e107170.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2023, Elsevier Publishing)

DOI

10.1016/j.aap.2023.107170

PMID

37331093

Abstract

This paper focuses on ex-post road safety evaluation with multiple treatments. The potential outcome framework for causal inference is introduced to formalize the causal estimands of interest. Various estimation methods are compared via performing simulation experiments based on semi-synthetic data constructed from a London 20 mph zones dataset. The methods under evaluation include regressions, propensity score (PS) based methods, and a machine learning-based method termed generalized random forests (GRF). Both PS-based methods and GRF show higher flexibility with respect to functional specifications of outcome models. Moreover, GRF shows great superiority in the cases where road safety treatments are assigned following specific criteria and/or where there are heterogeneous treatment effects. Considering the ex-post evaluation of combined effects of multiple treatments has significant practical value, the potential outcome framework and the estimation methods presented in this paper are highly recommended for road safety studies.

Language: en

Keywords

Machine learning; Causal effect; Multiple treatments; Potential outcome framework; Propensity score; Road safety evaluation