Citation

Gear C, Eppel E, Koziol-McLain J. Health Res. Policy Syst. 2018; 16(1): e99.

Affiliation

Centre for Interdisciplinary Trauma Research, Auckland University of Technology, Private Bag 92006, Auckland, 1142, New Zealand.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2018, Holtzbrinck Springer Nature Publishing Group - BMC)

DOI

10.1186/s12961-018-0373-2

PMID

30340495

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Integrating sustainable responses to intimate partner violence in health care is a persistent and complex problem internationally. New Zealand holds a leading role, having established national health system infrastructure for responding to intimate partner violence within hospital and selected community settings. However, resources for, and engagement with, the primary health care sector has been limited. The present study focuses on what affects a sustainable response to intimate partner violence within New Zealand primary health care settings.

METHODS: Utilising complexity theory, we reconceptualised a sustainable primary health care response to intimate partner violence as a complex adaptive system. To explore interactions between agents, we analysed the function(s) of key policy, strategy, guideline and evaluation documents informing intimate partner violence responsiveness in health care. We chronologically threaded these documents together by their function(s) to show how discourse influencing intimate partner violence responsiveness emerges from agent interactions.

RESULTS: This paper presents a complexity informed implementation narrative of the New Zealand health system response to intimate partner violence across the last two decades, focused on the participation of the primary health care sector. We demonstrate how competing discourses have contributed to system gaps and unintended consequences over time. Our findings consider implications for a sustainable response to intimate partner violence in primary health care and call attention to system interactions that challenge a whole health system approach in New Zealand.

CONCLUSIONS: Use of complexity theory facilitates an innovative perspective of a persistent and complex problem. Given the complexity of the problem and New Zealand's leadership, sharing the lessons learnt is critical for the international community involved in developing health care system approaches to intimate partner violence.

Language: en

Keywords

Complex adaptive system; Complexity theory; DHB District Health Board; Discourse; Document analysis; E Tu Whānau Programme of Action for Addressing Family Violence; GP General Practitioner; IPV intimate partner violence; Implementation; Intimate partner violence; MOH Ministry of Health; Narrative; Policy-making; Primary health care; Sustainability