CONTACT US: Contact info
|
Citation |
Lebensohn-Chialvo F, Rohrbaugh MJ, Hasler BP. Fam. Process 2019; 58(2): 305-317. |
|
Affiliation |
Department of Psychiatry, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA. |
|
Copyright |
(Copyright © 2019, Family Process Institute, Publisher John Wiley and Sons) |
|
DOI |
|
PMID |
29709061 |
|
Abstract |
As evidence-based family treatments for adolescent substance use and conduct problems gain traction, cutting edge research moves beyond randomized efficacy trials to address questions such as how these treatments work and how best to disseminate them to community settings. A key factor in effective dissemination is treatment fidelity, which refers to implementing an intervention in a manner consistent with an established manual. While most fidelity research is quantitative, this study offers a qualitative clinical analysis of fidelity failures in a large, multisite effectiveness trial of Brief Strategic Family Therapy (BSFT) for adolescent drug abuse, where BSFT developers trained community therapists to administer this intervention in their own agencies. Using case notes and video recordings of therapy sessions, an independent expert panel first rated 103 cases on quantitative fidelity scales grounded in the BSFT manual and the broader structural-strategic framework that informs BSFT intervention. Because fidelity was generally low, the panel reviewed all cases qualitatively to identify emergent types or categories of fidelity failure. Ten categories of failures emerged, characterized by therapist omissions (e.g., failure to engage key family members, failure to think in threes) and commissions (e.g., off-model, nonsystemic formulations/interventions). Of these, "failure to think in threes" appeared basic and particularly problematic, reflecting the central place of this idea in structural theory and therapy. Although subject to possible bias, our observations highlight likely stumbling blocks in exporting a complex family treatment like BSFT to community settings. These findings also underscore the importance of treatment fidelity in family therapy research. Language: en |
|
Keywords |
Adolescent Drug Abuse; Family Therapy; Treatment Fidelity; abuso de drogas en adolescentes; fidelidad al tratamiento; terapia familiar; 家庭心理治疗; 治疗保真; 青少年药物滥用 |