Citation

Nelson RM. Int. J. Wildland Fire 2015; 24(7): 1001-1007.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2015, International Association of Wildland Fire, Fire Research Institute, Publisher CSIRO Publishing)

DOI

10.1071/WF14155

PMID

unavailable

Abstract

During the past 20 years, study of wind-slope-aided wildland fire behaviour with experimental burns and physical modelling methods has increased. As part of their continuing study of fires in Mediterranean shrub, F. Morandini and X. Silvani reported experimental temperatures, heat fluxes, flame characteristics and other fire behaviour variables measured on five wind-slope-aided fires. Calculating convection numbers and several convective Froude numbers, the authors concluded that these dimensionless variables for their two wind-dominated fires did not satisfy criteria identified in previous studies for determining mechanisms of heat transfer during fuel preheating. The present paper describes a re-analysis of the data based on a triangular flame model and alternative definitions of flame tilt angle and height. This new analysis has shown that the influence of slope on the fire behaviour was not accounted for; thus, the conclusion of Morandini and Silvani is questionable. Of the five dimensionless variables studied using criteria in the literature, the squared flame height convective Froude number best describes modes of heat transfer to unburned fuels during the experimental fires. Though these results come indirectly from field measurements, they confirm the need to include slope effects in descriptions of wind-slope-aided fire behaviour.

Language: en