Citation

Sittig JS, Uiterwaal CS, Moons KG, Russel IM, Nievelstein RA, Nieuwenhuis EES, van de Putte EM. Ned. Tijdschr. Geneeskd. 2016; 160: D672.

Vernacular Title

Screening op kindermishandeling op de SEH.

Affiliation

*Dit onderzoek werd eerder gepubliceerd in BMJ Open (2016;6:e010788) met als titel 'Value of systematic detection of physical child abuse at emergency rooms: a cross-sectional diagnostic accuracy study'. Afgedrukt met toestemming.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2016, Erven Bohn)

DOI

unavailable

PMID

27848908

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: The aim of our diagnostic accuracy study Child Abuse Inventory at Emergency Rooms (CHAIN-ER) was to establish whether a widely used checklist accurately detects or excludes physical abuse among children presenting to ERs with physical injury.

DESIGN: A large multicentre study with a 6-month follow-up in 4 ERs in The Netherlands.

METHOD: Participants were 4290 children aged 0-7 years, attending the ER because of physical injury. All children were systematically tested with an easy-to-use child abuse checklist (index test). A national expert panel (reference standard) retrospectively assessed all children with positive screens and a 15% random sample of the children with negative screens for physical abuse, using additional information, namely, an injury history taken by a paediatrician, information provided by the general practitioner, youth doctor and social services by structured questionnaires, and 6-month follow-up information. Our main outcome measure was physical child abuse; secondary outcome measure was injury due to neglect and need for help.

RESULTS: 4253/4290 (99%) parents agreed to follow-up. At a prevalence of 0.07% (3/4253) for inflicted injury by expert panel decision, the positive predictive value of the checklist was 0.03 (95% CI 0.006 to 0.085), and the negative predictive value 1.0 (0.994 to 1.0). There was 100% (93 to 100) agreement about inflicted injury in children, with positive screens between the expert panel and child abuse experts.

CONCLUSION: Rare cases of inflicted injury among preschool children presenting at ERs for injury are very likely captured by easy-to-use checklists, but at very high false-positive rates. Subsequent assessment by child abuse experts can be safely restricted to children with positive screens at very low risk of missing cases of inflicted injury. Because of the high false positive rate, we do advise careful prior consideration of cost-effectiveness and clinical and societal implications before de novo implementation.

Language: nl