Citation

González-Wilhelm L, Moreno L, Carnevali R. Rev. Med. Chile 2016; 144(6): 772-780.

Vernacular Title

Consideraciones médico-legales sobre causal de violación contenida en el proyecto de Ley de Aborto actualmente en trámite.

Affiliation

Centro de Estudios de Derecho Penal, Facultad de Ciencias Jurídicas y Sociales, Universidad de Talca, Santiago, Chile.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2016, Sociedad Medica De Santiago)

DOI

10.4067/S0034-98872016000600013

PMID

27598498

Abstract

The Chilean senate is discussing a proposal to decriminalize abortion in 3 causals. One of these is when the pregnancy occurs as a result of a rape. To be legally able to perform the abortion in this circumstance, a health care team must confirm the occurrence of the facts constituting the offence. Regardless of the patient’s will, the accusation will be reported to the justice. In our view, in its current status the proposed rule does not consider certain medicolegal and procedural topics. Those flaws may determine in certain scenarios critical problems, such as: a) a wrongful conviction as a consequence of a false allegation of rape; (b) some pregnant due to a rape will not have access to the abortion procedure; (c) some accusations of rape will not be accredited nor criminally sanctioned. Employing a fictional case, we illustrate how those scenarios can actually be seen in practice. We also emphasize the difficulties and limitations that the health care team will encounter if the project is approved under the current conditions. Finally, we encourage the professional societies implicated in the theme to contribute in the legislatorial debate. Therefore, we give a set of proposals aimed to improve the bill before it may be enacted as a law.

Language: es