Citation

Vogel V, Louppen M. Int. J. Forensic Ment. Health 2016; 15(2): 174-185.

Copyright

(Copyright © 2016, Simon Fraser University - Mental Health, Law and Policy Institute, Publisher Informa - Taylor and Francis Group)

DOI

10.1080/14999013.2016.1170741

PMID

unavailable

Abstract

It has been suggested that female forensic psychiatric patients evoke different or stronger feelings in their treatment staff compared to male forensic patients. More specifically, it has been stated that it can be more difficult and emotionally draining to work with women as they are seen as more manipulative and demanding than men (Lewis, 2006). However, there is not much empirical research to support this suggestion. In this pilot study, 146 staff members working in a gender-mixed forensic psychiatric hospital filled out the Feeling Word Checklist 30-item version for their most complex, demanding, female and male patient. Overall, it was found that staff members felt more helpful, accepting, strong, relaxed, affectionate, sympathetic, and receptive towards their most complex female forensic patient and more anxious, threatened and overwhelmed by their most complex male forensic patient. Differences were found between more experienced and less experienced staff members as well as between female and male staff members. Staff members working over 5 years in this hospital experienced much fewer differences in feelings towards female and male patients. Less experienced staff had significantly more positive feelings towards female patients and more negative feelings towards male patients. Female staff members usually felt more strong and in control with female patients and more overwhelmed by male patients. Male staff members felt more angry with male patients and more receptive towards female patients. Compared to female staff members, male staff members felt more cautious and embarrassed with female patients. It was concluded that there are substantial differences in feelings of staff members towards female and male forensic patients, with staff reporting predominantly more positive feelings towards women. More training, intervision, and support with respect to working in forensic gender-mixed settings would be valuable, especially for mental health professionals who are early in their career. Finally, suggestions are provided for future research into this topic.