TY  - JOUR
PY  - 2008//
TI  - Media coverage of violent deaths in Iraq: an opportunistic capture-recapture assessment
JO  - Prehospital and disaster medicine
A1  - Siegler, Anne
A1  - Roberts, L.
A1  - Balch, Erin
A1  - Bargues, Emmanuel
A1  - Bhalla, Asheesh
A1  - Bills, Corey B.
A1  - Dzeng, Elizabeth
A1  - Epelboym, Yan
A1  - Foster, T.
A1  - Fulton, Latressa
A1  - Gallagher, Meghan
A1  - Gastolomendo, Juan David
A1  - Giorgi, Genessa
A1  - Habtehans, Semhar
A1  - Kim, Jaeyeun
A1  - McGee, Blake
A1  - McMahan, Andrew
A1  - Riese, Sara
A1  - Santamaria-Schwartz, Rachel
A1  - Walsh, F.
A1  - Wahlstrom, Jarl
A1  - Wedeles, John
SP  - 369
EP  - 371
VL  - 23
IS  - 4
N2  - INTRODUCTION: Western media coverage of the violence associated with the 2003 US-led invasion of Iraq has contrasted in magnitude and nature with population-based survey reports. OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the extent to which first-hand reports of violent deaths were captured in the English language media by conducting in-depth interviews with Iraqi citizens. METHODS: The England-based Iraq Body Count (IBC) has methodically monitored media reports and recorded each violent death in Iraq that could be confirmed by two English language media sources. Using the capture-recapture method, 25 Masters' Degree students were assigned to interview residents in Iraq and asked them to describe 10 violent deaths that occurred closest to their home since the 2003 invasion. Students then matched these reports with those documented in IBC. These reports were matched both individually and crosschecked in groups to obtain a percentage of those deaths captured in the English language media. RESULTS: Eighteen out of 25 students successfully interviewed someone in Iraq. Six contacted individuals by telephone, while the others conducted interviews via e-mail. One out of seven (14%) phone contacts refused to participate. Seventeen out of 18 primary interviewees resided in Baghdad, however, some interviewees reported deaths of neighbors that occurred while the neighbors were elsewhere. The Baghdad residents reported 161 deaths in total, 39 of which (24%) were believed to be reported in the press as summarized by IBC. An additional 13 deaths (8%) might have been in the database, and 61 (38%) were absolutely not in the database. CONCLUSIONS: The vast majority of violent deaths (estimated from the results of this study as being between 68-76%) are not reported by the press. Efforts to monitor events by press coverage or reports of tallies similar to those reported in the press, should be evaluated with the suspicion applied to any passive surveillance network: that it may be incomplete. Even in the most heavily reported conflicts, the media may miss the majority of violent events.<p />  <p>Language: en</p>
LA  - en
SN  - 1049-023X
UR  - http://dx.doi.org/
ID  - ref1
ER  -