TY - JOUR PY - 2008// TI - A failure to find empirical support for the homology assumption in criminal profiling JO - Journal of police and criminal psychology A1 - Doan, Brandy A1 - Snook, Brent SP - 61 EP - 70 VL - 23 IS - 2 N2 - A fundamental assumption in criminal profiling is that criminals who exhibit similar crime scene actions have similar background characteristics. We tested this so-called homology assumption by first classifying, with pre-existing typologies, a sample of arsons ( N = 87) and robberies ( N = 177) into different crime types and then comparing the background characteristics of criminals who committed the various crime types. Results showed that using pre-existing typologies to classify the crimes into mutually exclusive types was not easily accomplished. Notwithstanding classification difficulties, the homology assumption was violated in 56% of the comparisons of background characteristics between the different arson types and in 67% of the comparisons of background characteristics between the different robbery types. Overall, 73% of the effect sizes for the associations between crime type and background characteristics were low to moderate ( V < .3; d < .2). The implications of these findings for profiling practices are discussed.

LA - SN - 0882-0783 UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s11896-008-9026-7 ID - ref1 ER -