
@article{ref1,
title="Use of case vignettes in suicide risk assessment",
journal="Suicide and life-threatening behavior",
year="1990",
author="Sherman, R. E. and Stelmachers, Z. T.",
volume="20",
number="1",
pages="65-84",
abstract="Thirty-three brief case histories of suicidal patients were given to 19 experienced crisis workers for 7-point ratings of short- and long-term suicide risk. The ratings revealed considerable variability, raising questions about the reliability of such global assessments of suicidality. The most consistently rated cases were selected to operationally define &quot;mild,&quot; &quot;moderate,&quot; and &quot;high&quot; risk. Thus, each level was &quot;anchored&quot; by several vignettes. It was hoped that these anchor points would lead to more uniform future ratings among crisis workers. The correlation between short- and long-term risk ranged from near zero for some vignettes to as high as .82 (median = .46), demonstrating the need to rate both separately. Long-term risk was more difficult to rate, as demonstrated by a larger number of cases judged to be unrateable because of &quot;insufficient information&quot; (94 vs. 53 rater-case combinations). When the anchor vignettes were provided as a guide to the same sample of crisis workers, their ratings of suicide risk, as expected, showed significantly improved consistency.",
language="",
issn="0363-0234",
doi="",
url="http://dx.doi.org/"
}